Lily Collins’ Engagement Rings & Wedding Ring

Few celebrity engagement rings have captured the internet’s imagination quite like Lily Collins’ engagement ring. When the Emily in Paris star announced her 2020 engagement to writer-director Charlie McDowell, fans immediately zoomed in on the unusually romantic, vintage-inspired sparkler.

But the story of Lily Collins’ engagement ring doesn’t stop there. From a rare rose cut diamond to a shocking theft and now a breathtaking new 5 carat design, here’s everything you need to know, including how much Lily Collins’ engagement ring is worth, what her wedding ring looked like, and even the best Lily Collins engagement ring dupes for those wanting a similar look.

When fans search for Lily Collins engagement ring, this is the one they’re usually talking about – the jewel that launched a thousand Pinterest boards.

Charlie McDowell worked closely with LA jeweller Irene Neuwirth to design a completely bespoke engagement ring. The result was a whimsical ring design that looked like it had been pulled straight from a antique jewellery box.

The centre stone of Lily's first engagement ring was a rose cut, cushion-shaped light pink diamond, bezel set in warm yellow gold. The rose cut is known for its soft, candlelit glow, and paired with a full bezel and brushed gold finish, the ring has a distinctly vintage, heirloom feel.

Many publications called it a morganite, but Irene Neuwirth and Lily herself confirmed it was a rare and romantic rose cut diamond.

Queensmith gemmologist and design expert, Laura, estimates: 'Lily's original engagement ring looks to feature a 2-3 carat rose cut diamond, which would likely be worth over £65,000, or around $80,000.'

She adds, 'The rose cut is really unique – it's flat on the bottom, and domed and faceted on the top, which gives it a subtle, glowing sparkle rather than the modern brilliance we see with other diamond cuts.'

Alongside her original rose cut engagement ring, Lily wore a beautifully delicate diamond bezel set wedding band, crafted in 18k yellow gold. The design featured a fine line of tiny round diamonds, each enclosed in its own miniature bezel – a subtle echo of the unique framed setting of her engagement ring.

The effect was quietly luxurious: a band that shimmered with soft, evenly spaced flashes of light rather than a continuous glittering line. Its warm yellow gold perfectly matched the brushed gold of her engagement ring, creating a cohesive, vintage-leaning bridal stack.

Dainty, refined and full of character, it complemented the uniqueness of her rose cut diamond without overpowering it – a thoughtful, harmonious pairing that felt very true to Collins’ understated but artistic style.

While staying at a West Hollywood hotel spa in 2023, Lily Collins' engagement ring and wedding ring were stolen from a locker, with no sign of forced entry. The jewellery has never been recovered.

It was a heartbreaking loss – emotionally and artistically – given the ring’s bespoke design and Charlie’s involvement.

Fast-forward to 2025, and fans noticed a dazzling new sparkler in her photos, triggering a wave of fresh searches for Lily Collins' upgraded engagement ring. This time, the centre stone appears to be a 5 carat emerald cut diamond, set east-to-west in a sleek mixed metal bezel. The horizontal orientation gives the ring a contemporary, architectural feel, while the bezel keeps that smooth, old-world elegance she gravitates toward.

It’s bold, modern and effortlessly chic – a perfect evolution of her original ring.

Lily Collins’ new east-to-west emerald cut engagement ring is estimated at around £200,000 (approximately $250,000) if created with a high-quality natural diamond. A comparable lab grown diamond version would come in at roughly £15,000 (around $19,000), offering the same bold aesthetic at a fraction of the price.

Both of Lily Collins’ engagement rings – her original rose cut design and her new emerald cut upgrade – share one defining detail: a full bezel (or rubover) setting. The bezel’s smooth rim of precious metal frames the diamond with a soft, uninterrupted outline, giving her rings that signature blend of vintage romance and everyday practicality.

Bezel set engagement rings have been quietly gaining momentum in 2025, confirmed in our latest Engagement Ring Trend Report. Their appeal lies in their versatility: a bezel enhances the antique charm of a rose cut diamond just as effortlessly as it sharpens the clean geometry of an emerald cut, which is exactly why both of Lily’s rings feel so cohesive despite being very different designs.

She’s not alone in her preference either. Celebrities like Zendaya, Dua Lipa, Taylor Swift and Miley Cyrus have all embraced bezel or partial-bezel designs, helping push the style firmly into the spotlight. While prong settings still dominate, the rising interest in bezels reflects a move toward more refined, minimalist silhouettes – rings defined by craftsmanship and character. Lily Collins’ engagement rings capture this shift perfectly, proving just how timeless and quietly luxurious a bezel can be.

Interest in finding dupes of Lily Collins’ engagement rings has skyrocketed, and it’s easy to see why. You can recreate her look in a few ways:

For the original ring style:

• Choose a rose or cushion cut diamond
• Opt for 18k yellow gold, or rose gold for a touch of pink
• Pick a full bezel for that antique softness

For the new ring design:

• Choose an emerald or radiant cut
• Opt for a modern east-to-west setting
• Select yellow gold or mixed metals
• Keep the bezel sleek and modern

From her £65k rose cut original to her £200k emerald cut upgrade, Lily Collins’ engagement rings map a journey of love, loss and reinvention – each piece capturing a different side of her romantic, quietly luxurious style that continues to inspire.

Explore creating your own custom engagement ring, or book an appointment today with our design team to start your journey.